The Size of the Broad Line Region in M84 (NGC 4374)

Abstract

M84 is a giant elliptical galaxy located in the Virgo cluster. Prior imaging with the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) revealed a small, highly inclined, nuclear ionized gas disk, the kinematics of which indicate the presence of a 0.4 -1.5 billion solar mass black hole. Two prominent radio jets emerge perpendicular to the nuclear ionized gas disk terminating in large radio lobes that extend beyond the visible galaxy. Plausible kinematic models are used to constrain the size of the broad line region (BLR) in M84 by modeling the shape of the broad H-alpha emission line profile. The analysis indicates that the emitting region is large with an outer radius between ~ 7 and 9 pc, depending on whether the kinematic model is represented by a spherically symmetric inflow or a Keplerian disk. The inferred size makes the BLR in M84 the largest yet to be measured. The fact that the BLR in M84 is so large may explain why the AGN is unable to sustain the ionization seen there. Thus, the BLR in M84 is not simply that of a scaled down quasar.

Withdrawn from publication in the Astrophysical Journal, 25 August 2010. Reason: because M84 probably does not have a broad line region after all. I posted an e-print of the paper on astro-ph and was soon thereafter contacted by Aaron Barth who also has an M84 paper in production with ApJ. Aaron pointed out that a single component model for the superimposed narrow lines is insufficient because the narrow lines are expected to have broad wings. It turns out that a more plausible 2 component model can explain all of the emission that I was attributing to a broad line. The referee also raised the issue but I did not appreciate the full import of the comment